"The cats are starting to warm to him, I think. Poe is, certainly. Keats might take a bit," he added with a laugh. "They've both warmed to you, it seems."
Other options:
no subject
"The cats are starting to warm to him, I think. Poe is, certainly. Keats might take a bit," he added with a laugh. "They've both warmed to you, it seems."